•

Greg Vanney Has LA Galaxy in Tough Spot Before (And After) International Break

MLS: Sporting Kansas City at LA Galaxy
Credit: Kelvin Kuo-Imagn Images

Greg Vanney gets a chance to test just how strong his squad’s depth is as injuries and minutes begin to add up. 


Rotations bring up an interesting challenge in their next two league games, while their Concacaf Champions Cup matchup with CF Toluca presents their toughest opponent yet.


Yeah, the league table isn’t looking great, but the current anxieties surrounding the LA Galaxy are generally blown out of proportion. 


Two straight losses in the league and questionable decisions in the tie with Jamaica’s Mt Pleasant Academy (6-0 aggregate Galaxy win) have created an interesting backdrop for renewed “Vanney Out” cries.

Even though I’ve recently offered my harshest criticism of Vanney and the front office, my worries have less to do with how Vanney has the team playing and more to do with his failure to address some long-standing questions.

Defense in a Tough Spot

In the short term, a major injury, coupled with Vanney’s decision to rotate the squad in the league match against Sporting Kansas City in favor of the midweek Concacaf Champions Cup match, could hinder the team’s performance tomorrow and potentially in a week’s time as well.

Jakob Glesnes picked up a calf strain in practice before the SKC game, which will have him out of the squad for at least a month and up to 6 weeks, according to Greg Vanney. He obviously won’t be ready to face the Portland Timbers on Sunday.

Neither will Chris Rindov, who still doesn’t have a timeline for return from the injury that’s kept him out of the team all year so far. That leaves Maya Yoshida and Justin Haak, who started the last two games, and Emiro Garces, who just returned from injury, as the Galaxy’s centerback options.

Vanney now has to decide whether to start 37-year-old Maya Yoshida for the third consecutive game or field a lineup with a still-integrating Haak and a likely still-rusty Garces as starters.

You don’t want to see Yoshida start for the worry of overloading his aging legs and being short yet another centerback. Still, you also don’t want to see a lineup without any of his experience and all of the follies of youth.

It’s a difficult situation, especially considering the Galaxy’s recent defense-first shift. As Vanney said, “he doesn’t give a sh*t about scoring”, the Galaxy’s MO this year has been to defend well and take their chances when they come. Not counting on Glesnes, who has arguably been the most important part of the Galaxy’s defensive transformation, makes me less confident in their ability to keep it tidy in the back before scoring up front.

Midfield in a Tough Spot

What the Galaxy’s midfield looks like will also be unclear. Edwin Cerillo, Elijah Wynder, and Lucas Sanabria have established themselves as Vanney’s best midfield trio, but they also played significant minutes in Jamaica. 

Soccer: Concacaf Champions Cup-Round of 16-Mt. Pleasant at LA Galaxy
Credit: William Liang-Imagn Images

With the 3-0 lead in hand, Vanney could have absolutely decided to rest his entire starting 11 if he wanted to and comfortably played the strongest team for the upcoming games. Because he prioritised CCC over last week’s league match against SKC, Vanney must instead decide whether to over-reliance on key players or play a less-than-ideal team.

His ability or inability to set the current version of the Galaxy up for success will be crucial to setting the team’s ceiling. Performances like the 3-0 win against Charlotte and even the draw with New York City FC show that the Galaxy can compete with the group they have now. But the recent losses in the league also suggest Vanney might have to come up with something special to overcome an impressive Toluca team.

Vanney Ready for a Challenge?

Toluca is the Liga MX champion and currently sits in third place in their league. They bested the Galaxy as recently as last October when they killed Galaxy fans’ dreams of a title to lighten the pain of a miserable 2025 season. The Galaxy showed defensive weaknesses in their loss and will need Vanney to set them up for success if they are to avoid making it two straight big losses to Toluca.

The question will be whether Greg Vanney can figure out how to read and react so that his team is best equipped for the challenge he knows is coming. 

Not having the foresight to make the most of a 3-0 lead and rest more key players in Jamaica hurt the Galaxy against SKC, and it isn’t a great sign. Seeing how that decision set the team up for potentially more pain against Portland and even Minnesota United the following week makes it look even worse.


The 2026 Galaxy is a paradox.

They are a team capable of great things thanks to Greg Vanney’s ideas, but they are also capable of another tragic year if Vanney’s decisions continue to turn sour. It feels as though there is once again one man who can determine how far the Galaxy can go, except this time it’s not a small Spanish midfielder but an imposing and experienced American manager.



Discover more from Los Angeles Sports Nation

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

avatar
Andrew Hernandez is the Galaxy Nation Blogger for Los Angeles Sports Nation. A Galaxian desde la Cuna, he offers ... More about Andrew Hernandez
Tags:

Categorized: