The Skubal Deal is Just Business, Not the End of Baseball
If you’re a Dodgers fan, this trade deadline was thrilling. If you’re not, you probably rolled your eyes the second you saw the notification.
That’s pretty much how every big Dodgers move goes now.
The second they add another star, social media fills up with people saying they’re ruining baseball. I get why rival fan bases feel that way, but this trade honestly isn’t as deep as everyone is making it out to be.
The Dodgers traded for Tarik Skubal, sending outfielder Zyhir Hope and right-handed pitchers River Ryan and Brady Smith to Detroit. They also traded reliever Carlos Duran to the Royals for starting pitcher Kris Bubic.
On top of that, they brought catcher Ben Rortvedt back from the Mets in exchange for pitcher Chayce McDermott. Ben already knows the organization, and with Will Smith currently out since June with neck inflammation, getting him back is actually a really important move that people aren’t talking about enough.
Why Skubal Changes Everything
Obviously, Skubal is the headline. He’s one of the best pitchers in baseball, and adding someone like that before October changes everything. The Dodgers are chasing a historic third straight World Series title, and having another ace gives them an even better chance to get there. With Shohei Ohtani still working his way back as a pitcher, Skubal helps take pressure off the rest of the rotation.
The funny part is that people are acting like the Dodgers just signed him to a massive long-term contract. They didn’t. They traded for him. That’s a huge difference.
It’s Not a Long-Term Guarantee
Skubal’s contract is up after the season, so there is no guarantee he’ll even be with the Dodgers next year. If he wanted to play in Los Angeles no matter what, he could have just waited a few months and signed there in free agency. Instead, Detroit decided to make a trade, and the Dodgers happened to be the team that made the best offer. That’s how baseball works.
A lot of fans are also forgetting that the Dodgers still have to make decisions because of luxury tax penalties and future payroll constraints. Just because they traded for Skubal doesn’t automatically mean they’ll be able to keep him after this season. There’s a very real chance he leaves in free agency. So people acting like the Dodgers have locked him up forever are getting way ahead of themselves.
The “Ruining Baseball” Narrative Returns
What really makes me laugh is how every move the Dodgers make turns into another conversation about ruining baseball. Dodgers fans have been hearing this for years. It happened when they signed Ohtani. It happened when they signed Blake Snell. It happened with Yoshinobu Yamamoto. Now it’s happening again with Skubal.
At some point it just becomes predictable.
The Dodgers aren’t breaking any rules. They’re operating within the same system every other team has. They scout well, develop players, spend money, and make aggressive trades when they think it gives them a better chance to win. Every front office would love to do the same thing if they had the opportunity.
That’s why I don’t really understand the argument that this trade somehow hurts baseball. Teams trade stars all the time. Sometimes contenders get better. Sometimes rebuilding teams decide it’s the right time to move a player for future talent. That’s been part of baseball forever.
The Price of Landing an Ace
I also think people underestimate what the Dodgers gave up to make this happen. You don’t land one of the best pitchers in baseball without giving away valuable players. Trades aren’t free.
Los Angeles clearly believed that improving the major league roster right now was worth giving up talent for the future. Whether it works or not will depend on what happens in October.
Built to Win Right Now
From a baseball perspective, this move makes perfect sense. The Dodgers have one goal every season, and that’s winning the World Series. Nobody in that front office is thinking about whether fans on social media are going to complain. They’re trying to build the best roster possible while they have a chance to win another championship.
Skubal fits that plan perfectly. He’s the kind of pitcher you want starting a playoff game. He gives the Dodgers another reliable arm when every inning matters, and that’s something every contender is looking for this time of year.
Looking Ahead to October
As a Dodgers fan, I’m excited. I think he’ll be a huge piece of this team down the stretch, especially once the postseason starts. His first scheduled start against the Cubs is going to be must-watch baseball, and I’m really interested to see how he looks in a Dodgers uniform.
Will everyone else keep saying the Dodgers are ruining baseball? Probably. But honestly, it’s not that deep.
This wasn’t a $400 million free agent signing. It wasn’t some loophole nobody else can use. It was a trade. The Tigers made a decision, the Dodgers made an offer, and a deal got done. That’s baseball.
If Skubal helps bring another championship to Los Angeles, this trade will be remembered as one of the biggest moves of the season. If he leaves in free agency a few months from now, people will realize it wasn’t some permanent superteam move after all.
For now, the Dodgers got better, which is exactly what contenders are supposed to do. Whether people like it or not, that’s the reality.
And if you’re a Dodgers fan, you’re probably just counting down the days until Skubal takes the mound for the first time.
Discover more from Los Angeles Sports Nation
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.